Getting ready for a new school year means selecting the right supplies that balance quality, affordability, and versatility. The Sharpie School Supplies Variety Pack stands out as the best overall for its wide assortment of essentials, while the Crayola Colored Pencils are perfect for creative students. Price, durability, and usability are common tradeoffs in this category—higher quality often costs more, but cheaper options may lack longevity or performance. Keep reading for a detailed comparison that helps you pick the best supplies tailored to your needs.
Open a free Amazon Business account
Business pricing, bulk buying and tax-exempt orders.
Create a free accountAs an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The top-ranked supplies combine durability with affordability, making them suitable for everyday use.
- Pencil sets with pre-sharpened options save time and reduce frustration for students.
- Variety packs provide the most value, but sometimes sacrificing specialized tools for quantity.
- Brand reputation and product ratings heavily influence the best choices for longevity and reliability.
- Choosing the right supplies depends on the student’s age and specific needs—more creative tools for arts, basic essentials for general use.
| Sharpie School Supplies Variety Pack, 31 Count |  | Best Overall Back-to-School Supplies Pack | Count: 31 | Includes: Highlighters, dry erase markers, pencils, erasers, glue sticks | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown | |
| EXPO Dry Erase Markers, Assorted Colors, 12 Count |  | Best for Clear, Vibrant Whiteboard Writing | Ink Type: Low Odor | Number of Markers: 12 | Tip Type: Chisel | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Trail Maker School Supplies Kit 45 Piece Grades K-12 |  | Best for All-in-One Multi-Grade Use | Number of Pieces: 45 | Includes: Pencils, pens, colored pencils, highlighters, folders, crayons, scissors, erasers, notebooks, glue sticks, ruler | Suitable Grades: K-12 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Amazon Basics Wood-Cased #2 HB School Pencils with Erasers, Pre-sharpened, 30 Count |  | Best for Basic Writing and Drawing Needs | Quantity: 30 pencils | Lead Hardness: HB | Color: Orange | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Amazon Basics Wood-Cased #2 Pencils, 150 Count |  | Best for Bulk, Long-Term Use | Quantity: 150 | Lead: #2 HB | Eraser: Top eraser | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Crayola Colored Pencils (36 count) |  | Best Creative Set for Beginners and Gift-Giving | Quantity: 36 | Suitable for: Kids & Adults | Ages: 3+ | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Mead Spiral Notebook, 1 Subject, College Ruled, 7.5 x 10.5 inches, 70 Sheets, 6 Pack |  | Best Organized Note-Taking for Multiple Subjects | Brand: Mead | Unit Count: 6 | Sheet Size: 7.5 x 10.5 inches | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| BIC Xtra Smooth Bright Edition Mechanical Pencils, 0.7 mm Medium Point, 40-Count Pack |  | Best for Smooth, Precise Writing in Class or Exams | Point Size: 0.7 mm | Count: 40 | Design: Mechanical, Refillable, Retractable | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Ticonderoga Wood-Cased Pencils, Pre-Sharpened |  | Best Reliable Pencil for Everyday School Use | Graphite Formula: Exclusive #2 | Wood Material: Premium, responsibly managed forests | Eraser: Latex-free, securely glued | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Oxford Spiral Notebook 6 Pack, 1 Subject, College Ruled, 8 x 10.5 Inches, Assorted Colors |  | Best Color-Coded Organization for Multiple Subjects | Quantity: 6 | Subject: 1 | Page Size: 8 x 10.5 inches | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Sharpie School Supplies Variety Pack, 31 Count
This 31-piece set stands out for its comprehensive collection of essentials, offering a mix of highlighters, dry erase markers, pencils, and more from trusted brands like Sharpie and Elmer’s. Compared with the Trail Maker kit, it provides a broader assortment of individual items, making it ideal for students who want a versatile starter pack. However, it lacks specific details on the quantity of each item, which could be a drawback for those needing precise amounts, and it doesn’t include any branded notebooks or folders. Still, for overall value and variety, this pack covers most back-to-school needs in one purchase.
Pros:- Contains a wide variety of essential school supplies
- Includes trusted brands like Sharpie, Paper Mate, Expo, and Elmer’s
- Suitable for a broad range of back-to-school needs
Cons:- No specific details on individual item quantities
- No price information available
- Lacks customer ratings for quick quality assessment
Best for: Parents seeking a broad, all-in-one supply kit for multiple children or classroom use
Not ideal for: Students who prefer brand-specific or high-quality individual items and need detailed specifications
- Count:31
- Includes:Highlighters, dry erase markers, pencils, erasers, glue sticks
Our verdict“This pack is best for families or teachers wanting a comprehensive, budget-friendly supply stash for multiple students.”
EXPO Dry Erase Markers, Assorted Colors, 12 Count
This set excels by offering vibrant ink colors with a versatile chisel tip, making it easy to write in various line widths on whiteboards, glass, or acrylic surfaces. Compared to the Sharpie set, these markers are specifically designed for whiteboard use, providing clearer visibility, especially for presentations or classroom lessons. A potential downside is that color assortment may vary, and the popular yellow marker can sometimes be unavailable, limiting options for color coding or emphasis. Still, their ease of erasing makes them a favorite for teachers and students alike.
Pros:- Vibrant ink for high visibility
- Versatile chisel tip for multiple line widths
- Easily erasable from non-porous surfaces
Cons:- Color assortment may vary, affecting consistency
- Limited to whiteboard use, not suitable for paper or art projects
Best for: Teachers or students who need reliable, vibrant markers for daily whiteboard use
Not ideal for: Students looking for markers for detailed art or drawing, as the chisel tip is less precise for fine lines
- Ink Type:Low Odor
- Number of Markers:12
- Tip Type:Chisel
- Color:Assorted colors
Our verdict“Ideal for classroom and presentation settings where vibrant, erasable markers are essential.”
Trail Maker School Supplies Kit 45 Piece Grades K-12
This 45-piece set offers a complete range of supplies, from pencils and pens to scissors, crayons, and notebooks, tailored for students from kindergarten through middle school. Compared to the smaller Sharpie pack, it covers a broader spectrum of everyday needs and includes safety-compliant items suitable for younger kids. The tradeoff is that the quality of individual items isn’t specified, which may be a concern for parents expecting durable, high-quality tools. Nonetheless, its comprehensive nature makes it perfect for homeschooling, summer camps, or classrooms where variety is key.
Pros:- Comprehensive set with all essential school supplies
- Suitable for a wide range of grades from K-12
- Safety compliant and kid-friendly design
Cons:- Limited information on individual item quality
- No specific brand reputation details provided
Best for: Parents of younger children or educators needing a wide, all-in-one starter kit
Not ideal for: Students or parents seeking high-end or brand-specific supplies, or those requiring detailed quality info
- Number of Pieces:45
- Includes:Pencils, pens, colored pencils, highlighters, folders, crayons, scissors, erasers, notebooks, glue sticks, ruler
- Suitable Grades:K-12
- Safety Compliance:Yes
Our verdict“This kit is well-suited for broad, budget-conscious supply needs across multiple grade levels.”
Amazon Basics Wood-Cased #2 HB School Pencils with Erasers, Pre-sharpened, 30 Count
This 30-pack of pre-sharpened #2 HB pencils offers a straightforward, affordable solution for daily writing, drawing, or sketching. Compared with the 150-count pack, it’s ideal for smaller households or classrooms with fewer students. Its pre-sharpened tip ensures immediate use, and the included eraser helps with quick corrections. However, the lack of a grip feature might make extended writing sessions less comfortable, and the uniform orange color offers limited personalization or color coding. For those needing a simple, reliable pencil, this is a solid choice but less suited for detailed artistic work.
Pros:- Pre-sharpened for immediate use
- Versatile for writing, drawing, and sketching
- Includes top eraser for easy corrections
Cons:- No grip feature for enhanced hold
- Limited to #2 HB hardness, less suited for advanced art
Best for: Students or teachers needing reliable, immediate-use pencils for everyday tasks
Not ideal for: Artists or students requiring specialized drawing tools or color variety
- Quantity:30 pencils
- Lead Hardness:HB
- Color:Orange
- Material:Wood
- Pre-sharpened:Yes
- Line Size:0.5mm or 0.7mm
Our verdict“This pencil pack offers reliable, ready-to-use writing tools suitable for general schoolwork and basic drawing.”
Amazon Basics Wood-Cased #2 Pencils, 150 Count
This massive 150-pack of pre-sharpened #2 HB pencils is perfect for large families, classrooms, or anyone who wants a long-term supply of reliable pencils. Compared with the smaller 30-pack, it offers unmatched value for bulk needs, with pre-sharpened tips and easy erasers for quick corrections. The main tradeoff is the absence of color variety or specialized features, and the bulkiness may be cumbersome for portability or storage. Still, for budget-conscious shoppers or bulk buyers, this pack offers exceptional longevity and convenience.
Pros:- Pre-sharpened for immediate use
- Ideal for high-volume needs at a budget-friendly price
- Includes erasers for easy corrections
Cons:- Limited to #2 HB lead, less suitable for artistic or technical drawing
- No color variety, basic design only
- Potentially bulky for portable use
Best for: Large households, teachers, or schools needing bulk supplies for multiple students
Not ideal for: Students seeking colorful or specialized pencils, or those with limited storage space
- Quantity:150
- Lead:#2 HB
- Eraser:Top eraser
- Dimensions:7.4 x 0.3 x 0.3 inches
Our verdict“This bulk pack is best for those requiring a large, affordable supply of reliable pencils for everyday school or office use.”
Crayola Colored Pencils (36 count)
This set of 36 vibrant Crayola colored pencils offers a solid palette for casual artists, students, and gift buyers. Compared to larger sets like the 150-count Amazon Basics pencils, this option is more manageable for younger children or those just starting out. While the limited color range may restrict detailed artwork, the presharpened tips ensure immediate use without hassle. The durability of these pencils makes them a reliable choice for school projects and creative hobbies, but the smaller selection could fall short for advanced artists needing a broader spectrum. This pick excels for beginners or as a gift rather than for extensive professional art.
Pros:- Vibrant colors enhance creative projects
- Presharpened and durable for long-term use
- Suitable for kids and adults, versatile for gifts
Cons:- Limited to 36 colors, may need more for complex artwork
- Not ideal for professional-level art or detailed coloring
Best for: Parents and students seeking an easy-to-use, vibrant coloring option for school projects or gifts
Not ideal for: Advanced artists or hobbyists requiring extensive color options for detailed work
- Quantity:36
- Suitable for:Kids & Adults
- Ages:3+
- Color Range:Vibrant
- Sharpening:Presharpened
- Durability:Long-lasting
Our verdict“This set is perfect for beginners or casual users who want reliable, vibrant pencils without the complexity of larger collections.”
Mead Spiral Notebook, 1 Subject, College Ruled, 7.5 x 10.5 inches, 70 Sheets, 6 Pack
This Mead 6-pack of spiral notebooks offers a practical solution for students juggling multiple classes or projects. The college-ruled pages and perforated sheets make note-taking and clean tear-outs simple, while the coated covers with writable labels add a layer of durability and customization. Compared with the Oxford 6-pack, this set provides more uniform quality, but the assorted colors are randomly selected, which might not match every aesthetic. For students who prefer neat, organized notes across different subjects, these notebooks are a reliable choice. However, if you need notebooks tailored to specific color-coding preferences, the random color selection could be a drawback.
Pros:- Color-coded for easy subject separation
- Micro-perforated pages for clean removal
- 3-hole punched for binder compatibility
Cons:- Colors are randomly assigned, not customizable
- Limited to one subject per notebook, requiring multiple purchases
Best for: Middle or high school students looking for organized, durable notebooks for multiple classes
Not ideal for: Students requiring specific color-coded notebooks or those who prefer larger formats for extensive note-taking
- Brand:Mead
- Unit Count:6
- Sheet Size:7.5 x 10.5 inches
- Number of Sheets:70 per notebook
- Cover Material:Coated
- Color:Assorted
Our verdict“Ideal for students who want durable, organized notebooks for multiple classes without fuss over colors.”
BIC Xtra Smooth Bright Edition Mechanical Pencils, 0.7 mm Medium Point, 40-Count Pack
This pack of BIC Xtra Smooth Bright Edition mechanical pencils emphasizes smooth, consistent writing, making them suitable for exams, note-taking, and detailed assignments. The 0.7 mm medium point strikes a balance between fine detail and durability, unlike the thinner 0.5 mm options. Compared to traditional wood pencils like the Ticonderoga, these mechanical pencils reduce sharpening time and mess, though the bulk 40-pack might be excessive for casual users. Refillable and retractable, they support long-term use, but the limited point size means they aren’t versatile for different drawing needs. This set is best suited for students and teachers prioritizing neat, smudge-free writing.
Pros:- Smooth, smudge-free writing surface
- Refillable and retractable for durability
- Ideal for consistent, neat notes
Cons:- Limited to 0.7 mm point size, less versatile for drawing
- Bulk pack may be unnecessary for casual users
Best for: Students and teachers who need reliable, smooth writing tools for daily use and exams
Not ideal for: Artists or hobbyists requiring varied tip sizes or specialized drawing tools
- Point Size:0.7 mm
- Count:40
- Design:Mechanical, Refillable, Retractable
- Suitable For:Students, Teachers
Our verdict“This pack makes the most sense for students or educators who want reliable, neat writing tools for everyday tasks.”
Ticonderoga Wood-Cased Pencils, Pre-Sharpened
The Ticonderoga #2 pre-sharpened pencils are a staple for classrooms thanks to their smooth performance and high-quality graphite. Their proprietary formula ensures consistent lines, making them ideal for standardized testing and daily note-taking. Compared with the Amazon Basics 150-pack, these are more convenient for individual use and less overwhelming to store, though they come in a single size and hardness. The pre-sharpened feature saves time and reduces frustration, but their limited size and lack of color options mean they’re less versatile for art projects or color coding. Made from responsibly managed forests, these pencils prioritize safety and sustainability.
Pros:- Smooth performance with proprietary graphite
- Pre-sharpened for immediate use
- Made from responsibly sourced wood
Cons:- Limited to #2 graphite, less suitable for shading or artistic variation
- No color or size options
Best for: Students and artists seeking dependable, high-quality pencils for writing and basic drawing
Not ideal for: Artists needing a variety of colors or different hardness levels for specialized work
- Graphite Formula:Exclusive #2
- Wood Material:Premium, responsibly managed forests
- Eraser:Latex-free, securely glued
- Pre-Sharpened:Yes
- Certification:PMA certified non-toxic
Our verdict“This pick suits students or basic artists who want reliable, ready-to-use pencils for everyday writing and drawing.”
Oxford Spiral Notebook 6 Pack, 1 Subject, College Ruled, 8 x 10.5 Inches, Assorted Colors
The Oxford 6-pack of 1-subject spiral notebooks offers a practical way to organize different classes or projects with color-coded covers. The college-ruled paper and micro-perforated sheets facilitate neat writing and easy page removal, making them suitable for students who want to keep their notes orderly. Compared with the Mead 6-pack, these notebooks have a slightly larger page size, which can accommodate more detailed notes or sketches. The color assortment helps visually separate subjects, but the random color assignment might not suit users with specific aesthetic preferences. Overall, these notebooks are a reliable choice for organized note-taking across multiple classes.
Pros:- Color-coded for easy subject identification
- Micro-perforated pages for clean removal
- 3-hole punched for binder use
Cons:- Color assortment may vary, not customizable
- Limited to one subject per notebook, requiring multiple purchases
Best for: High school or college students who want a simple, organized system for multiple subjects
Not ideal for: Students who prefer uniform aesthetics or specific color schemes for their notes
- Quantity:6
- Subject:1
- Page Size:8 x 10.5 inches
- Sheets per Notebook:70
- Ruling:College ruled
- Perforation:Micro-perforated
Our verdict“This set makes sense for students who value color-based organization and clean, easy note management.”
How We Picked
We evaluated these back to school supplies based on performance, usability, build quality, and value. Each item was selected for its ability to meet the typical demands of students across different grade levels, from elementary to high school. We balanced affordability with durability, ensuring that the picks would withstand regular use without breaking the bank. The ranking reflects a combination of customer reviews, brand reputation, and versatility, focusing on products that offer the best overall experience for various student needs.Factors to Consider When Choosing Back To School Supplies
Choosing the right back to school supplies involves more than just picking colorful pens or pencils. It’s important to consider durability, versatility, and the specific needs of the student. Overbuying can lead to waste, while underspending might mean replacing supplies frequently. The following factors will help narrow down your options and avoid common pitfalls, ensuring you get the best value and performance for your money.Durability and Build Quality
Supplies that are well-made last longer and resist wear and tear, which is especially important for items like notebooks and writing instruments. Cheaper products often break or dull quickly, leading to repeated purchases. For students who write a lot or are rougher on their supplies, investing in sturdier options can pay off in the long run. However, premium materials typically come with a higher price tag, so balance your budget with expected usage before choosing higher-end options.
Versatility and Suitability
Consider whether the supplies match the student’s grade level and activities. For example, basic pencils and notebooks work well for general note-taking, while art supplies like colored pencils or markers are better suited for creative projects. Multi-purpose kits can reduce clutter and simplify shopping, but may lack specialized features. Think about the specific tasks the student will perform most often to select supplies that support those needs efficiently.
Cost and Value
Pricing varies widely, and while it might be tempting to buy the cheapest options, they often require replacement sooner. Conversely, high-end supplies may offer better performance but could be unnecessary for casual use. Buying in bulk can be a smart way to save, especially for items like pencils and notebooks that get used quickly. Focus on finding a balance between quality and price to maximize value without overspending.
Brand Reputation and Reviews
Trusted brands tend to deliver more consistent quality, which reduces the likelihood of disappointment. Customer reviews can reveal real-world performance and durability, helping you avoid poorly made products. For essential items like notebooks and writing tools, investing in reputable brands can save money over time by preventing frequent replacements. Be cautious of lesser-known brands that may lack quality control or reliable performance.
Environmental and Safety Considerations
Eco-friendly materials and non-toxic inks or paints are increasingly important for safety and sustainability. Look for supplies that are labeled as environmentally friendly or made from recycled materials, especially for younger students. Non-toxic products reduce health risks, and choosing sustainable options can contribute to broader environmental goals. Keep in mind that these features might come at a slightly higher price but can be worth it for peace of mind.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I choose the right notebooks for my child’s grade level?
Matching the notebook size, ruling style, and durability to your child’s grade ensures they have a suitable space for notes and assignments. Elementary students often do well with smaller, durable notebooks, while older students might prefer larger or college-ruled options for more extensive notes. Consider whether the student needs a lightweight, portable option or a sturdier, comprehensive binder. Investing in quality notebooks can make a noticeable difference in usability and longevity throughout the school year.
Are multi-purpose supplies better than specialized tools?
Multi-purpose supplies are usually more economical and space-efficient, making them ideal for general use or for students with limited storage. However, specialized tools like high-quality art markers or technical pencils can enhance performance in specific tasks and improve the learning experience. If your child participates in art or technical subjects regularly, investing in specialized tools makes sense. For basic schoolwork, versatile supplies often suffice and provide better value.
Should I buy supplies in bulk or individual packs?
Buying in bulk can significantly reduce costs, especially for frequently used items like pencils, pens, and notebooks. It’s a practical choice for families with multiple children or for stocking up early in the school year. However, bulk purchases might include items that your child doesn’t need immediately or that aren’t suitable for their grade. Consider your storage space and the specific needs of the student before committing to large quantities—sometimes smaller, targeted purchases are more effective.
How important are eco-friendly supplies for school?
Eco-friendly supplies are increasingly important for reducing environmental impact and ensuring safety for children. Items made from recycled or biodegradable materials, and those labeled non-toxic, can be safer and more sustainable choices. While they might cost a bit more, many parents find value in supporting environmentally responsible products. Additionally, choosing eco-friendly options can teach children about sustainability and responsible consumption, making it a worthwhile consideration beyond just immediate needs.
What’s the best way to organize supplies for the school year?
Effective organization starts with selecting the right containers—like pencil cases, folders, or small storage bins—that keep supplies accessible and tidy. Labeling items and keeping frequently used supplies in easy-to-reach spots can save time during busy mornings. It’s also helpful to involve the student in organizing their supplies to foster responsibility. Regularly checking and replenishing supplies ensures that the student always has what they need for assignments and projects.
Conclusion
For the most well-rounded choice, the Sharpie School Supplies Variety Pack offers excellent value and versatility, making it ideal for families seeking a comprehensive set. The Crayola Colored Pencils are perfect for artistic students or projects, while the Amazon Basics Pencils provide affordability for bulk needs. If budget is a concern, the Trail Maker School Supplies Kit delivers good quality at a lower price point, suited for elementary students. For those looking for premium options, investing in durable, branded supplies can reduce replacements over time. Ultimately, selecting the right supplies depends on your child’s grade level, activities, and your budget—use this guide to find the best fit for your back-to-school shopping.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.Flea & tick season Picks
flea and tick prevention
